# Sign Paradox in Berry's Phase

+ 1 like - 0 dislike
430 views

Suppose we have normalized states $| n(\vec{R})\rangle$ indexed by continuous variable $\vec{R}$. Then fixing our choice of gauge and ignoring dynamic phase, the phase difference between two states is the Berry's Phase:

$$\tag{1} \langle n(\vec{R}_0)| n(\vec{R}_0 +\Delta \vec{r} ) \rangle ~=~ e^{i\gamma}$$

where, if $C$ is some curve that goes between $\vec{R}_0$ and $\vec{R}_0 + \Delta \vec{r}$, $$\tag{2} \gamma~=~i\int_C \langle n(\vec{R}) | \nabla_{\vec{R}} | n(\vec{R})\rangle \cdot d\vec{R}$$

If $\Delta \vec{r}$ is small, then $$\tag{3} \gamma \approx i\langle n(\vec{R}_0) | \nabla_{\vec{R}} | n(\vec{R}) \rangle \Big|_{\vec{R}=\vec{R}_0} \cdot \Delta \vec{r}$$

However, we can directly calculate this as well:

$$\langle n(\vec{R}_0)| n(\vec{R}_0 +\Delta \vec{r} ) \rangle ~\approx~ \langle n(\vec{R}_0) | n(\vec{R}_0) \rangle + \langle n(\vec{R}_0) | \nabla_{\vec{R}}| n(\vec{R}) \rangle \Big|_{\vec{R}=\vec{R}_0} \cdot \Delta \vec{r}$$

$$\tag{4} \approx 1 + \langle n(\vec{R}_0) | \nabla_{\vec{R}} | n(\vec{R}) \rangle \Big|_{\vec{R}=\vec{R}_0} \cdot \Delta \vec{r} ~\approx~ \text{exp}\left[ \langle n(\vec{R}_0) | \nabla_{\vec{R}} | n(\vec{R}) \rangle \Big|_{\vec{R}=\vec{R}_0} \cdot \Delta \vec{r} \right]$$

and therefore

$$\tag{5} \langle n(\vec{R}_0)| n(\vec{R}_0 +\Delta \vec{r} ) \rangle ~\approx~ e^{-i\gamma}$$

There's a minus sign now! What am I doing wrong here?

This post imported from StackExchange Physics at 2014-03-24 04:13 (UCT), posted by SE-user ChickenGod
I suspect there is a mistake in your Taylor expansion, but I wasn't able to track it down. It strikes me as odd that you start with only $\tau$ and $\Delta\tau$ but take a $t$ derivative.

This post imported from StackExchange Physics at 2014-03-24 04:13 (UCT), posted by SE-user Flavin
@Flavin I don't see anything wrong with the Taylor expansion: $f(a+h) \approx f(a)+h f'(a)$

This post imported from StackExchange Physics at 2014-03-24 04:13 (UCT), posted by SE-user ChickenGod

+ 2 like - 0 dislike

Comments to the question (v2): OP's second equation

$$\tag{2} \gamma~=~i\int_{0}^{t_f} \langle \psi_n(t) | \frac{d}{dt} | \psi_n(t)\rangle dt.$$

is not correct. It should read

$$\tag{A} \gamma_n(t_f) ~=~i\int_{0}^{t_f} \! dt \langle n, R(t)| \frac{d}{dt} | n,R(t)\rangle,$$

Here

$$\tag{B} |\psi_n(t_f) \rangle~=~e^{i\gamma_n(t_f)}\exp\left[-\frac{i}{\hbar}\int_{0}^{t_f} \! dt ~E_n(R(t)) \right] | n,R(t_f)\rangle,$$

cf. Wikipedia. In particular, the rhs. of OP's second eq. (2) [multiplied by $\hbar$] reads

$$\tag{C} i\hbar\int_{0}^{t_f} \! dt \langle\psi_n(t)| \frac{d}{dt} | \psi_n(t)\rangle ~=~ i\int_{0}^{t_f} \! dt \langle\psi_n(t)| \hat{H} | \psi_n(t)\rangle ~=~\int_{0}^{t_f} \! dt ~E_n(R(t)).$$

Comments to the update (v3): In the revision (v3), the Berry phase $\gamma$ in eq. (1) has the wrong sign.

This post imported from StackExchange Physics at 2014-03-24 04:13 (UCT), posted by SE-user Qmechanic
answered Nov 7, 2013 by (3,110 points)
Maybe I'm being really stupid right now, but I fail to see the difference between your equation (A) and my equation (1) if you set $\tau=0$, $\Delta \tau = t_f$, and symbolically change $\psi$ to $R$.

This post imported from StackExchange Physics at 2014-03-24 04:13 (UCT), posted by SE-user ChickenGod

This post imported from StackExchange Physics at 2014-03-24 04:13 (UCT), posted by SE-user Qmechanic
Sorry, I guess the way I posed my question was confusing. I didn't intend $t$ to be time, but rather just some parameter to index the states. I revised my question for clarity.

This post imported from StackExchange Physics at 2014-03-24 04:13 (UCT), posted by SE-user ChickenGod
In the revision (v3), the Berry phase $\gamma$ in eq. (1) has the wrong sign.

This post imported from StackExchange Physics at 2014-03-24 04:13 (UCT), posted by SE-user Qmechanic
Your previous comment was very cryptic. At first glance, my eq. (1) looks like it agrees with your eq. (B). However, after some deep thought, I think I understand. Thanks!

This post imported from StackExchange Physics at 2014-03-24 04:13 (UCT), posted by SE-user ChickenGod

 Please use answers only to (at least partly) answer questions. To comment, discuss, or ask for clarification, leave a comment instead. To mask links under text, please type your text, highlight it, and click the "link" button. You can then enter your link URL. Please consult the FAQ for as to how to format your post. This is the answer box; if you want to write a comment instead, please use the 'add comment' button. Live preview (may slow down editor)   Preview Your name to display (optional): Email me at this address if my answer is selected or commented on: Privacy: Your email address will only be used for sending these notifications. Anti-spam verification: If you are a human please identify the position of the character covered by the symbol $\varnothing$ in the following word:p$\hbar$ysicsOv$\varnothing$rflowThen drag the red bullet below over the corresponding character of our banner. When you drop it there, the bullet changes to green (on slow internet connections after a few seconds). To avoid this verification in future, please log in or register.