Quantcast
  • Register
PhysicsOverflow is a next-generation academic platform for physicists and astronomers, including a community peer review system and a postgraduate-level discussion forum analogous to MathOverflow.

Ron Maimon

Edit your profile
First posted: 6 years
Type: Registered user
Extra privileges: Voting on questions
Voting on answers
Voting posts down
Recategorizing any question
Editing any question
Editing any answer
Editing any comment
Vote on comments
Full name: Ron Maimon
Location: New York City
Website:
About:

The site has a great potential, hopefully it will not be over-moderated.

Activity by Ron Maimon

Score: 7,525 points (ranked #3)      (breakdown)
Questions: 37
Answers: 239
Comments: 1,474
Voted on: 280 questions, 362 answers
Gave out: 532 up votes, 110 down votes
Received: 614 up votes, 3 down votes

Wall for Ron Maimon

Please log in or register to post on this wall.
Roooooon
Jan 7, 2016 by WolfInSheepSkin
Hi Ron, what's up? Have you heard about Roko's basilisk? I think this is a ridiculous idea.
Nov 13, 2015 by WolfInSheepSkin
I meant "not when there aren't moderators" below, obviously, not "not when there are moderators".
May 4, 2015 by Ron Maimon
By the way, that tactic, of stopping the discussion and crying "rude", is extremely common when someone exposes a fatal flaw in your thinking. In physics, I saw this happen personally many times, I was sometimes guilty! When you realize you are wrong in a stupid way you should have seen in the beginning, the natural defense mechanism is to say "no, that's not what I meant, you're twisting my words..." instead of "oops, I goofed." It doesn't work online, at least not when there are moderators, because the arguments are in text and leave a permanent trace. The usenet debates were off-the-charts in terms of rudeness, but exposed serious issues in academia. For example, the Torvalds Tannenbaum debate about microkernels was basically Linus Torvalds saying "all Kernel academics are stupid about microkernels", and he was right, and it wasn't accepted until 2006, when it was revisited. It still isn't accepted by everyone, but it is accepted by everyone who develops kernels! That's good enough.
May 4, 2015 by Ron Maimon
I deliberately over-use it, to test for Sams. I don't want to deal with Sams.
May 4, 2015 by Ron Maimon
Now I got your point. But I think your use of it is a bit too much.
May 4, 2015 by WolfInSheepSkin
Hi Ron, you might read this: http://www.alternet.org/belief/sam-harris-made-himself-look-idiot-email-exchange-chomsky-and-has-shared-it-world
It seems that Chomsky agrees with your view that offensive language is sometimes necessary. Citation: "...And I agree that I am litigating all points (all real, as far as we have so far determined) in a “plodding and accusatory way.” That is, of course, a necessity in responding to quite serious published accusations that are all demonstrably false, and as I have reviewed, false in a most interesting way..."  And now I realize what you mean. Because Sam stopped discussing the topic because he (as you can read) wrote that Chomsky was too offensive (rephrased in my words). So it helped to expose the truth a bit I think. If Chomsky wasn't right, then it should be easy for Sam to refute some of Chomsky's arguments, but he just stopped the discussion and cried about Chomsky's language. (sry for the edits)
May 4, 2015 by WolfInSheepSkin
I fixed the dollar signs. In future, you can use the collapse sidebar button to get the buttons back. I think I know how to fix the bug...
Apr 30, 2015 by dimension10
A little bit of authority means that you are allowed to remove spam, decide whether things are off-topic, and remove gibberish and plagiarism, and that other people have the authority to remove you from authority if you do any more than this. Authority is not an on-off property, it's a continuum you grant, and this site grants as little as possible to the moderators and as much as possible to "the people".
Apr 26, 2015 by Ron Maimon
What does "a little bit authority" even mean? It's the same with free speech, either you have it or you don't. Or that you are a little bit pregnant, doesn't make sense. (that was the last one)
Apr 25, 2015 by WolfInSheepSkin




user contributions licensed under cc by-sa 3.0 with attribution required

Your rights
...