• Register
PhysicsOverflow is a next-generation academic platform for physicists and astronomers, including a community peer review system and a postgraduate-level discussion forum analogous to MathOverflow.

Welcome to PhysicsOverflow! PhysicsOverflow is an open platform for community peer review and graduate-level Physics discussion.

Please help promote PhysicsOverflow ads elsewhere if you like it.


New printer friendly PO pages!

Migration to Bielefeld University was successful!

Please vote for this year's PhysicsOverflow ads!

Please do help out in categorising submissions. Submit a paper to PhysicsOverflow!

... see more

Tools for paper authors

Submit paper
Claim Paper Authorship

Tools for SE users

Search User
Reclaim SE Account
Request Account Merger
Nativise imported posts
Claim post (deleted users)
Import SE post

Users whose questions have been imported from Physics Stack Exchange, Theoretical Physics Stack Exchange, or any other Stack Exchange site are kindly requested to reclaim their account and not to register as a new user.

Public \(\beta\) tools

Report a bug with a feature
Request a new functionality
404 page design
Send feedback


(propose a free ad)

Site Statistics

198 submissions , 156 unreviewed
4,910 questions , 2,086 unanswered
5,311 answers , 22,546 comments
1,470 users with positive rep
805 active unimported users
More ...

  The greatest quadruple moment

+ 2 like - 0 dislike

Let us consider the following problem:  it is necessary to find the shape of the body with fixed mass and density which at large distances compared with its characteristic dimensions would give the greatest deviations from the strength of the gravitational field of the material point with the same mass placed in the center of the mass of the object. I understand that in this case the dipole moment is zero and it is necessary to maximize all the components of the quadruple moment tensor of the object. It is naturally that it is necessary to use a variation calculus. But I can’t make specific calculations. Please, help me with a solution to this problem.

asked Nov 27, 2018 in Open problems by reterty [ no revision ]

1 Answer

+ 2 like - 0 dislike

The biggest part of your problem is finding out the right formulation. I formulate it like this: let there be a body of mass $M$, volume $V$, and a constant density $\rho = M/V$ that is within a ball $B_R$ of radius $R$ around its center of mass. What shape, holding the parameters above fixed, maximizes the mass quadrupole $Q$ of the body?

Let us pick spherical coordinates $r,\vartheta,\varphi$. Let me assume axisymmetry for now, and you can verify later that it cannot extremize the problem further. We then use the formula for the mass quadrupole in terms of spherical harmonics, divide it by the total mass, and find out that we are then maximizing the following expression with respect to $V$

$$\frac{Q}{M} = \frac{\int_V r^2\frac{1}{2}(3 \cos^2 \vartheta-1) 2 \pi r \sin \vartheta dr d\vartheta}{\int_V 2 \pi r \sin \vartheta dr d\vartheta}$$

where I have cancelled the factor $\rho$ in both the expressions but let the geometric factors uncancelled for better transparency.

Technically, I do not immediately see how to make a tidy expression $\delta Q/ \delta V$ while keeping the body within $B_R$, but I know the solution to the problem because it is obvious from the structure of the extrema of the harmonic $r^2(3 \cos^2 \vartheta-1)/2$. The extrema do not exist within the domain of finite volumes $V$. However, there are two asymptotic extrema corresponding to an extremely prolate ($Q>0$) and extremely oblate ($Q<0$) body. They are respectively the infinitesimal volumes around two points at the poles $\vartheta = 0,\pi$ at a distance $R$ from the center, and an infinitely thin ring at $\vartheta=\pi/2$ of radius $R$.

answered Nov 28, 2018 by Void (1,645 points) [ no revision ]

Dear Dr. Void! Thank you so much for your very elegant solution to this problem. I guessed about these asymptotic cases, since I know that the field strength at the center of the ring is zero and that binary stars have a large quadrupole moment. But what can you say about an infinitely thin rod with a length equal to twice the radius of the sphere?

@reterty No need for the titles, we are not at a university here :) I believe the rod of the same mass would have a three times smaller quadrupole then the two point masses. This is because of the $r^2$ factor in the harmonic and it integrating out to $R^3/3$ along the rod.

Dear Void! Your solution is valid for any symmetrical system with the polar axis of symmetry with order greater than 2 (3, 4, 5...).  So, the curve for $\theta=\pi/2$ can be more complex then circle. But I have a problem with its construction again:). Another words we can try to find the closed curve  with the $Q<Q_{\rm ring}  $\($\theta$\)

The formula above (Q/M) is just a number. In order to figure our the body shape, one has to admit a variable density (from zero to infinity) in the integrand: $\rho=\rho(r,\theta,\varphi)$.

Not really infinity since a dot shape is excluded and density is always positive. I agree with Vladimir that the spherical density has a meaning here. I upvoted the above answer elegance. However, it is not very physical in the strict conditions of the question.

The alternative reterty answer with many bodies doesn't correspond to the question: 1 body, 1 density without pressure consideration and explicitely, since it is related to a cosmic observation, stability. The interesting question is, given a matter resistance and a density, what is the biggest body able to be stable without sphericity. Don't forget the 3D-pressure.

Your answer

Please use answers only to (at least partly) answer questions. To comment, discuss, or ask for clarification, leave a comment instead.
To mask links under text, please type your text, highlight it, and click the "link" button. You can then enter your link URL.
Please consult the FAQ for as to how to format your post.
This is the answer box; if you want to write a comment instead, please use the 'add comment' button.
Live preview (may slow down editor)   Preview
Your name to display (optional):
Privacy: Your email address will only be used for sending these notifications.
Anti-spam verification:
If you are a human please identify the position of the character covered by the symbol $\varnothing$ in the following word:
Then drag the red bullet below over the corresponding character of our banner. When you drop it there, the bullet changes to green (on slow internet connections after a few seconds).
To avoid this verification in future, please log in or register.

user contributions licensed under cc by-sa 3.0 with attribution required

Your rights